Monday, August 28, 2006
Apology for Insult at the Cenotaph
eCouncillor readers would remember my post on representing the City of Sydney at the VP Day memorial service at the Cenotaph, Martin Place. It was a moving ceremony and a great honour.
Read the post here.
Imagine my anger at opening today's newspapers to see what I feel is a desecration of this sacred place. I visited Martin Place yesterday but the offensive display (in the name of art?) that greeted us on page 5 of today's Sydney Morning Herald had been removed by that time. Just as well with dozens of Vietnam diggers wandering through the Cenotaph attending a reception at government House in their honour. I think it was a pretty appalling oversight by our organisation to let this desecration occur. When I saw it in the SMH I was very angry and disappointed that we had been so insensitive, so careless. I know some will feel that all the victims of war have a right to be acknowledged. Body bags around the Cenotaph is an insult to the respectful memorial of all who die in wars. The impact upon returned service men and women, their families and those who did not return must be paramount in our thinking about uses for the Cenotaph.
The new CEO's report to Councillors is below along with the article form today' SMH. The picture is at the link (Blogger is getting very difficult to upload images).
Bags of controversy over cenotaph display
Stark ... Omeima Sukkarieh, the artist responsible for the display, said she had not intended it to be near the Cenotaph, a placement that has angered the RSL.Photo: Dean Sewell
Jordan Baker and David HumphriesAugust 28, 2006
THE City of Sydney has come under attack from the Returned and Services League for allowing hundreds of mock body bags - including one labelled "your prime minister" - to surround the Cenotaph in Martin Place.
The artist, Omeima Sukkarieh, said the display was supposed to be a stark reminder of innocent lives lost in war. That it surrounded a monument to real soldiers who were killed in war was an accident.
"Honestly, I really wanted to have it either at Circular Quay or Hyde Park," she said. "It was never intended to be Martin Place. It was just the only place available."
Sukkarieh said she had complied with the City of Sydney Council's protocols. "It was never meant to cause any disrespect, and if it did I apologise," she said.
The national president of the Returned and Services League, Bill Crews, said he would have been offended if Sukkarieh had staged a political protest beside the memorial to make a point. But in this case, the council should have been more careful.
"I take [the artist's] assurance that they didn't deliberately do it at the Cenotaph, but in that case the onus comes on the council for agreeing [to let it be] adjacent to the cenotaph," he said.
The body bags each had an identity meant to shock, such as "your daughter", "your prime minister" or "your doctor".
Sukkarieh said the display was intended to draw attention to the victims of war, particularly those killed in recent conflicts in Iraq, Afghanistan and Lebanon.
"There were some people who were not impressed and found it disgusting," Sukkarieh said. "But what's going on is disgusting. I respected everyone's opinions. It just made people think."
The body bag labelled "your prime minister" was not supposed to refer to John Howard but to a generic prime minister, she said.
"One had an ambulance officer, a journalist, a doctor. Death doesn't discriminate against people, and I think it's really about us realising as human beings that, prime minister or no prime minister, we are all the same."
The council was unable to comment last night.
The Minister for Veterans Affairs, Bruce Billson, said this "graphic demonstration" showed "a lack of respect for our service men and women who have given their lives".
"This could be quite traumatic for those who lost loved ones in conflicts while serving our country," Mr Billson said.
He said there were many alternative sites that would have been "more thoughtful and sensitive", and Martin Place was "totally inappropriate".
Lord Mayor & Councillors
I refer to the article on p.5 of today's Sydney Morning Herald regarding the display by Omeina Sukkarieh which used the Cenotoph as a backdrop.
I have written to the State President of the RSL (Don Rowe) to apologise for any offence or disrespect that this may have caused. I have also verbally apologised to the State Secretary of the RSL, Chris Perrin, who is also Custodian of the Cenotopaph.
The City receives many applications for use of Martin Place around the Cenotaph, and such applications are rarely approved (with the exception of events organised by the RSL). In the very few instances where approval is contemplated the City always consults with and seeks endorsement from the Custodian of the Cenotaph, Chris Perrin, who is also the NSW State Secretary of the RSL.
In this case the applicant was verbally advised that the display was to have been in the area between Castlereagh and Pitt Streets, not near or around the Cenotaph. Unfortunately the written approval provided to the applicant did not make this clear.
I have spoken with the staff involved and asked that procedures be reviewed to ensure that this does not occur again.
Monica Barone
Chief Executive Officer
Friday, August 18, 2006
Harmony script
Mallard launches Cycle Strategy...
Cycling in the City Program a huge success Participants in the City’s Cycling in the City program were recognised at a cycling breakfast at Customs House this week.
More than 30 representatives of the ten government and corporate organisations that took part in the program attended the event, with most arriving by bike.
Councillor Shayne Mallard, himself a keen cyclist, presented certificates to the organisations and also launched the City’s 10-year cycle strategy, which is currently on public exhibition.
More than 100 cyclists have cycled more than 31,000kms on their journeys to work over the 12-week program, which provides peer support to help more people ride their bicycles to work on a regular basis. Participating organizations included ANZ, Westpac, the Australian Taxation Office and City of Sydney.
This stage of the Cycling in the City program has been a huge success, with more than 95 per cent of the participating cyclists indicating they will continue to ride to work and all ten organisations committing to supporting their cyclists in the future.
Major bike groups also attended the event to extend their thanks to the fledgling cyclists, who also received a free breakfast.
Pictured above are Councillors John McInerney (left) and Shayne Mallard at the awards presentation.
Thursday, August 17, 2006
Mallard presents Cycling in the City awards
I was pleased to represent Council at the awards presentation for the successful 'Cycling in the City Program'. The program outlined by the City Media Centre below saw more than 100 cyclists ride their bikes commuting to work in the CBD covering 35,000 kms in 12 weeks. I rode my bike (as I regularly do) to make the presentations for 8am at Customs House. I don't usually ride to the North of the CBD but the experience again underlines the work to be done in providing basic safer bicycle infrastructure in our city. See below for details of the program and a link to the Draft Bicycle strategy currently on exhibition.
City of Sydney Cycling in the City Program Huge Success
15 August 2006
Participants in City of Sydney's Cycling in the City program will be recognised at Customs House tomorrow (August 16) at 8.00am.
More than 100 cyclists from ten leading government and corporate organisations have cycled more than 31,000 kms on their journeys to work over the 12 week program. The program is designed to help more people ride their bicycles to work on a regular basis through peer support.
Program participants, at least thirty of whom will arrive by bicycle, will be presented with certificates by City's Councillor Shayne Mallard.
Participating organisations in the Cycling in the City program included ANZ, Westpac, the Department of Environment and Conservation, IAG, the RTA, the Australian Taxation Office, Lend Lease, Telstra Wholesale, the City of Sydney and AMP. Each organisation nominated an average of ten cyclists to participate in the program.
Each cyclist received free intensive cycle safety training, free bicycle maintenance training, free membership of Bicycle NSW and other equipment. In return the cyclists had to commit to riding to work once a week on average for twelve weeks and provide the City with data from their rides.
This stage of the Cycling in the City program has been a huge success, with more than 95% of the participating cyclists indicating they will continue to ride to work and all ten organisations committing to supporting their cyclists in the future.
This event comes at an exciting time for the City of Sydney as it launches its ten year cycle strategy, designed to increase the number of trips made by bike from the current 2 per cent, to 10 per cent by 2016.
City of Sydney's cycle strategy is on public exhibition until end September 2006. It plans to connect each of the city's villages with a network of bicycle routes, make city streets safer for cyclists and set in place a range of activities to promote cycling and its benefits. For more information see: www.cityofsydney.nsw.gov.au/Council/OnExhibition/
Wednesday, August 16, 2006
Oxford Street Revitalisation
Council's plan to redevelop our property holdings at 56 - 76 Oxford Street (view proposal on Council's web site here as item 2 with PDF attachments) is to incorporate a large 1st floor food hall, ground floor specialty food shops and rear lane (Folley Lane) eat street will dramatically improve and diversify the offering at this end of Oxford Street. I believe the development worth tens of millions will act to attract visitors to the strip and generate a business renewal. I doubt though that it will contribute to reducing thee rents.
Oxford Street is baring all, and it's no Mardi gras
Elizabeth Farrelly
Twenty years back, in its heyday, Oxford Street exemplified this diversity. Rents were low and shops brimmed with the adventurous and the experimental. To walk the walk was to have a cultural adventure, never knowing what might come next.
Gradually, though, as success led to consumerism, Oxford Street snowcloned itself under avalanching boutique and chainstore cliches. Rents skyrocketed and adventure went west, to Newtown.
So when the vacancies began, it was easy to take a Darwinist stance, seeing it as a natural correction that would send the chainstores scuttling back home to the mall, reduce rents and, after initial pain, return the creatives.
Sydney turns White
Sydney received an unexpected white dusting yesterday as an unexpected hail storm turned the streets white. Some of Council's properties were damaged (details below) but in general the storm passed without too much hardship. The temperature dropped 10 degrees in 30 minutes! People running in the hail and cars not reducing their speed as they sped past Town hall where I took these happy snaps. It was all over in 30 minutes and the ice melted away in 60 minutes.
5 Council properties have been affected :Hilder Booler- water damage to switchboard, ceilings and carpet, centre unlikely to open tomorrow.
Pyrmont Community Centre- water damage area roped off centre can function
Paddington Town Hall- Cinema ceiling and sound system damaged unlikely to open tonight or tomorrow some other areas affected
Redfern Day Care- some water damage assessment needed
94 Oxford- water penetration assessment in progress
Wednesday, August 09, 2006
'Harmony Park' reconciles Council's past actions
In the case of the proposed park on the former Police Centre car park, Council resolved on 27 February to seek community consultation and input with six names suggested. The result of the consultation survey is available on line on this link as item 3 of the Finance Committee agenda: http://web-internal/Council/MeetingsAndCommittees/2006/Committees/310706/finance.asp
In particular I refer to clause 14 where you can see that 169 people responded to the survey and that no one name achieved an outright majority of support. The results were:
Surry Hills Park 52 responses 30.7%
Barrabarri Park 45 responses 26.6%
Harmony Park 33 responses 19.5%
Milk Park 29 responses 17%
balance 10 responses
Councillors debated the merits of the various names and I moved that we support 'Harmony Park'. Not on the basis of the proposed 'Surry Hills Park' name being boring but because I strongly believe the naming of a new public space like this is a rare opportunity to take a historical perspective and interpret it for contemporary times and future generations.
The land of the park and neighbourhood has a strong and troubled historical connection to Sydney's early Chinese community and local government actions. The area of Goulbourn Street, Poplar Street and Wentworth Avenue were home to a significant community of Chinese Sydneysiders at the turn of the 1900's. At this time the City of Sydney engaged in 'slum clearance' particularly after an outbreak of bubonic plague that was largely attributed to the 'slums' and the Chinese community by authorities of the time. This must be considered in the context of the White Australia policies of the time.
"In 1905 The Municipal Council (City of Sydney) was given power to resume properties ... One of the first to go was Wexford Street (to make way for Wentworth Avenue).. which housed large numbers of Sydney's Chinese community and in those days newspapers showed no hesitation in heaping contempt on them. Lurid stories of opium dens, gambling holes and brothels staffed by kidnapped white girls made good copy" (Pictorial History of South Sydney p64).
I feel that the name 'Harmony' that has strong Chinese resonance as well as contemporary harmonious connotations for our troubled times is an excellent historically relevant name for the new park and one that leaves a 2006 legacy for future generations to consider and interpret. It is in a sense a reconciliation for the City with the spirit of those thousands who were evicted and suffered at the hands of the Council during that time (not only the Chinese).
Some including several Councillors put the casethat we were ignoring community views as expressed in the responses to the survey. That is not the case. Councillors are elected to make decisions and in doing so consult their constituents and the community. The survey results were not clear cut and there was in fact no majority opinion. Council decisions are not popularity contests but rather the debate and weighing up of various views, evidence and reports. In this instance our staff offered one option and several alternatives as they are required to do. Council then is in an informed position to make the final decision.
Some details on Harmony park from Council's web site:
http://www.cityofsydney.nsw.gov.au/Development/CityImprovements/SurryHillsPark.asp
The new park will cost $3.6 million to construct – and is the first new open space in the CBD in many decades. The park is being developed on the former Energy Australia construction site and Police Centre car park, between Goulburn, Brisbane and Hunt Streets. The park will service some 5,000-plus residents and CBD workers within the surrounding district, with the emphasis on landscaped open and green space for casual activity.
The remediation of contamination is complete and clean imported fill laid across the site. The new park landscape works are well underway. Heavy rains caused some delays in early June. The in-ground water storeage tank on the corner of Brisbane and Goulburn Street has been constructed to capture, treat and store stormwater for park irrigation purposes. Stairs, retention walls and paths are now under construction. Park lights have been installed and mature trees delivered to site. Decking and paving will commence shortly. The park is due to be completed by September 2006.
http://www.sydneymedia.com.au/html/2796-lord-mayor-turns-first-sod-on-new-cbd-park-.asp
Development of the 7,000 square metre site follows agreement between the City of Sydney, NSW Police and Energy Australia. The agreement has allowed Energy Australia to work on part of the land for its tunnelling and service connections into a new substation building, located between the park and the Police Centre.
The park was designed as a collaboration between Council's City Projects department and landscape architects Spackman & Mossop, and in consultation with environmental scientists and arborists.
- Features include:
A series of lawn terraces connected by embankments across the natural slope of the site that will provide for informal recreation;
An upper lawn terrace that will serve as an area for people to meet and sit while enjoying views across the park;
A palette of trees including new native, evergreen and deciduous trees as well as garden beds and lawn areas to supplement existing trees and create a strong framework to the park's open centre.
A variety of park entry points making the area easily accessible and highly visible from adjacent streets and buildings;
Clear park signage and disabled access;
A north-south pedestrian pathway providing for better access through to neighbouring areas;
An in-ground water storage tank that will collect storm water and treat and purify it for reuse in the irrigation of the park grounds.
Tuesday, August 01, 2006
Barons looks safe for now
Council Committees met last night and will do so again tonight to clear a record number of DA's and reports including the Hyde Park masterplan and Bicycle Strategy. On a long list of development applications is one to demolish a Kings Cross landmark. I strongly oppose the demolition and called on Council to reject the proposal even though staff recommended approval. I am pleased to report that the application was refused at Committee last night and that should be concluded at Council on Monday night. The applicants options are now to either go to court and overturn the Council decision or come back with a new DA involving restoration and adaptive re-use of the buildings. Either way Barons is not out of danger yet.
MEDIA RELEASE
Mallard calls on Council to save the last of Kings Cross' unique character
Liberal Sydney City Councillor Shayne Mallard has called upon the City Council to act now and save the rapidly disappearing unique character of Kings Cross by tossing out the application to demolish the much loved 'Barons' bar and restaurant on Roslyn Street, Kings Cross.
This Monday night Council's Planning Development Committee will consider an application to demolish the three intertwined buildings that date back to the 1880's and to replace them with a four storey modern building containing a restaurant and commercial offices.
Shayne Mallard said that , ÂThis represents yet another loss to the unique character of Kings Cross and itÂs gone far enough.Â
"Council has successfully managed the ongoing clean up of Kings Cross and the economic renewal is now well underway, however we must act urgently to save the last buildings of Kings Cross' unique bohemian past."
"Barons and the related small businesses are the last examples of the much loved Kings Cross of yesteryear".
In calling for the refusal of the demolition Shayne Mallard points to the lack of independent research by Council on the social heritage of the buildings and no evidence in the reports of any proposed adaptive reuse of the existing buildings.
"This is an opportunity to restore the buildings and preserve the unique heritage streetscape of Roslyn Street. "
"Heritage value is not just about bricks and mortar - it must include the human and social history of a place."
"The demolition of Barons will be the end of the Kings Cross of old - the Kings Cross that attracted the artists, musicians and the unique characters to the area for over a century."
In strongly opposing the proposal Councillor Shayne Mallard said he was acting in the interests of residents and businesses in the area.
"The community strongly objects to this proposal with 51 submissions and a 1118 signatures on a petition all calling for the retention of the heritage buildings and preservation of the mixed small shops at street level."
"The demolition of Barons will be the sad farewell to the bohemian Kings Cross of yesteryear."
Councillor Shayne Mallard is a member of the Planning Committee. It will meet from 530pm on Monday 31st July at Sydney Town Hall Council Chambers. Members of the public are encouraged to attend.
The details of the Development Application including colour images are available on-line
http://www.cityofsydney.nsw.gov.au/Council/documents/meetings/2006/Committee/Planning/310706/31-07-06_PDTC_ITEM4.pdf
RELEASE ENDS
28 July 2006
Monday, July 10, 2006
eCouncillor on winter break too!

Tuesday, July 04, 2006
Log Cabin Republicans show the way
Sign up on the email link at bottom to keep up to date with LCR. @eC
Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger Makes Strong Case for Equality at Log Cabin Republicans Dinner in Los Angeles
(Los Angeles, CA) An overflow crowd of over 375 people joined special guests Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger and first lady Maria Shriver at an event to support the work of Log Cabin Republicans. In a rousing speech, Schwarzenegger declared that he was "committed to being a Governor for all Californians" and was "proud to stand side by side with Log Cabin in their work to offer basic fairness for gay and lesbian citizens." He went on to say, "A person should only be limited by his dreams and not by his background, and not by his heritage and not by his sexual orientation...We are united in the values of love, tolerance, and understanding?working together we can create a better future for California where everybody matters and every family counts."
Log Cabin endorsed and campaigned for Arnold Schwarzenegger in the 2003 recall election and continues to support his efforts to bring people together to build an even brighter future for the great state of California. "When he took the oath of office, Arnold Schwarzenegger said he would be governor of all the people-and he reinforced that inclusive message in his first-ever address to a gay and lesbian organization," added Guerriero.
"Governor Schwarzenegger has been reaching out to all Californians from all walks of life in every corner of the state. He has a record of supporting inclusive civil rights legislation and broadening the Republican big tent to include all Californians," continued Guerriero.
The event also recognized Marc Cherry, the Creator and Executive Producer of "Desperate Housewives." San Diego District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis presented Log Cabin's American Visibility Award to Cherry.
Log Cabin presented Schwarzenegger with its Ronald Reagan Award. This award recognizes those individuals who maintain a big tent philosophy by working for the inclusion of all Americans in the Republican Party. The award is named after former California Governor and President Ronald Reagan for his leadership in helping defeat the 1978 Briggs Initiative. This proposal would have barred openly gay and lesbian people from teaching in California public schools. Reagan's courageous opposition to this anti-gay initiative inspired the founding of Log Cabin Republicans in California 30 years ago. The evening also looked back at the 30 year history of Log Cabin.
Previous Log Cabin awards have been given to Gov. M. Jodi Rell (R-CT), Gov. William Weld (R-MA), Gov. Christine Todd Whitman (R-NJ), California Secretary of State Bruce McPherson, Sen. Gordon Smith (R-OR), Sen. John McCain (R-AZ), Sen. John Danforth (R-MO), Mayor Richard Riordan (R-L.A.), U.S. Rep. Mary Bono (R-CA), U.S. Rep. Tom Campbell (R-CA), and U.S. Rep. Jim Kolbe (R-AZ), among many others.
Since taking office in 2003, Governor Schwarzenegger has signed over a dozen gay and lesbian supportive bills including expansion of domestic partnership rights, hate crimes protection, housing and employment non-discrimination laws, improving HIV/AIDS prevention and treatment strategies, and ending the Don't Ask, Don't Tell policy in the state militia. The Governor has spoken out against the anti-family Federal Marriage Amendment and has been one of the nation's leading voices advocating for a "Big Tent" Republican Party.
Following passage of marriage equality legislation in 2005, Governor Schwarzenegger stated that he was awaiting a ruling by the California Supreme Court regarding the constitutionality of any prohibition on the freedom to marry for all Californians regardless of sexual orientation. In his veto message, he also stated that, "I believe that lesbian and gay couples are entitled to full protection under the law and should not be discriminated against based on their relationships."
"This event also offered Log Cabin a chance to put a face on the thousands of life long, law abiding, tax paying gay and lesbian families who support full equality. The gathering also celebrated the bright and inclusive future of the Republican Party as embodied by the leadership of Governor Schwarzenegger," concluded Patrick Guerriero.
Log Cabin Republicans is the nation's largest organization of Republicans who support fairness, freedom, and equality for gay and lesbian Americans. Log Cabin has state and local chapters nationwide, full-time offices in Washington, DC and Sacramento, CA, and a federal political action committee. www.logcabin.org
READ A NEWS ARTICLE ABOUT THE EVENT
Visit the web address below to tell your friends about this. Tell-a-friend!
If you received this message from a friend, you can sign up for Log Cabin Republicans.
Friday, June 23, 2006
Pyrmont Water Police Site to serve broad Community Needs
Tonight the Council will endorse a masterplan for the new park at the former water Police site. This will bring to a conclusion the successful process of acquisition and extensive community consultation about the park's future. The local community, staff and consultants are to be congratulated on the excellent level of engagement in this process. Calls, faxes and emails are still arriving as various points of view are being promoted up to the 11th hour. Consultation is an interesting concept. Many believe it means the result wil incorporate every single view expressed in the consultation process or that a consensus or compromise will result. Those not happy with the outcome will argue the consultation process was ignored or flawed and those satisfied will stand by the process.
Community consultation such as that undertaken for the water police site delivers up to the Council the catchment of local and user views. Professional independent local government staff, landscape architects, engineers and consultants pull this process together into a report for the Council. Tonight is the stage where the Councillors - elected by 130,000 people from across the city, bring to the table their input to the process. Often at community consultation forums and workshops the Councillors are asked not to make input but to merely observe, taking into account that their obligation to the process is to shape and interpret the outcome at the Council chamber.
And so tonight 10 Councillors will debate the final plans for the controversial site and bring to the table the broader city perspective and responsibilities.
I am impressed with the recommendation from Council's staff. (Full report with attachments here). The contentious issues in the master plan are well described in the letter to today's Sydney Morning Herald. Balancing a well organised campaign against certain controversial elements of the masterplan are residents and users in support of the proposals. The points of contention is summary are:
- inclusion of a community use building under the cliff face between in the south western corner.
- the central shoreline walk through the park.
- relocation of the existing children's playground.
- access stairs from Pirrama Road to the cliff top of Pyrmont.
Some of the controversy unintentionally reflects the age old debate about what is a park? Some - such as the SMH letter writer have a more traditional Capability Brown view of open space (Capability Brown landscaped the great 19th century English estates with romantic grand rivers and vistas) versus others (including eCouncillor) who have a philosophy for urban parkland spaces attuned to the great 20th century landscape architect Roberto Burle Marx combining a built form understanding the urban environment creating a lyrical landscape of human scale and use. Some call this style 'over engineered' and others 'urban scale'.
I feel the masterplan for Pyrmont Point park balances the two philosophies without too many compromises. Significant open spaces lined with fig trees and eucalyptus plantings allow ample green vistas to the water whilst steps and pathways mark the historical alignment of the shoreline and permit transition from the hard built forms of the surrounding neighbourhoods.
The inclusion of the community building and related stairs is a point of difference where Councillors should be taking into account the broader needs of the community, value for community investment and longer term strategic planning. Again the concept of well scaled built form between the narrowed and realigned road and the cliff face with flat roof-top gardens and contemporary connecting stairs joining through two levels to the parkland below is an exciting response to the built environment and the parkland forshore below. Very Burle Marx. eCouncillor supports the community space because the responsible expenditure of tens of millions of dollars from across the City of Sydney ratepayers into this site needs to be a sustainable community investment. A future community use for this remote but strategic corner is an appropriate return for the broader community across the city and allows the site to cater for a larger cross section of community members - whether youth, elderly, multi-cultural, arts or others user groups. The stairs connecting via the roof of this building to the park below from the cliff above will provide another appropriate element of human and urban scale whilst at the same time improving the permiability and access for the community to and from the many homes and streets above.
Much emmotive debate has centred on the relocation of the children's playground. On a recent site inspection the case was made for the new location based on closer proximity to the proposed pavilion with toilets and sheltered seating. Moving the play equipment away from the waters edge has some demonstrated safety benefits. In many ways relocating the play equipment area to the more urban designed elements of the space and in turn opening up the point area to green space and uninterrupted water vistas is an appropriate balanced landscape design response and a logical amendment to the park after the addition of the new space and in effect the amalgamation of the parklands at Pyrmont.
No doubt the future of this important new urban parkland will continue to arouse impassioned public debate - not just between landscape philosophers.
Wednesday, June 14, 2006
Farrelley adjudicates on Moore & Sartor brawl.
Once-bullied Sartor grows up and becomes a bully
Elizabeth FarrellyJune 14, 2006
IT'S that dumb-and-dumber feeling you get when someone grabs your hand and makes you slap yourself, hard, in the face. It's how the City of Sydney council must be feeling right now.
Last Wednesday, after 18 months of haggling with Foster's over a "voluntary planning agreement" on the Carlton and United Breweries site on Broadway, and moments from a joint announcement, the council found itself formally asking the planning minister to step in and take over. Uh, please, sir, kick me.
Say what? Why would it do that? Threats? Coercion? Ventriloquism? Well yes, actually.
The story starts here. Since 1991, all serious council planning decisions have been made not by the council but by the Central Sydney Planning Committee.
Four of the committee's seven members - a carefully appointed majority - take marching orders directly from the state but its decisions are still, legally, those of the council. This is a lie, but it's a legally stipulated lie, designed for market consumption.
What market? Us. Most of us regard most development with something between shock and horror. At the same time, and especially if we don't have to look, we want construction, jobs and economic growth.
The committee is designed to schmooze this electoral paradox, ensuring that the council wears the blame (who in God's name approved that?!) while the state gets both control and credit for growth, such as it is.
It's smart, but it's not honest. An honest system - or planning minister - would have said, two years ago when the CUB process was rebooted after the mayoral elections, "this site is way too lucrative for you local government pissants, so the state will annexe it to Redfern-Waterloo, though it is patently not Redfern-Waterloo, so we can exact developer levies under the ever-flexible Redfern-Waterloo Authority Act. To placate the developer, a major party contributor, we must of course raise heights and densities well past what is reasonable, while loosening energy-saving targets for those same, high-energy developments. You understand. It's simple dollar arithmetic."
But that isn't what the minister, Frank Sartor, said. Instead, he told Parliament: "The second untruth I need to correct is the notion that [the Redfern-Waterloo Act] is a cash-grab by the Government. As if we would try to redevelop Eveleigh or Waterloo as a cash grab!"
As if. Now, the Government proposes 18 storeys for Eveleigh-Waterloo and more than 33 for the CUB site, while in the same breath halving Basix requirements for residential towers. Cash grabbing, back scratching and bullying in a single, practised move.
Bullying? It's that old playground graduation from bullied to bully. Like when, in 2000, Bob Carr invited the then lord mayor Sartor to adopt the cash-starved Museum of Contemporary Art. He waited until the council had spent 18 months and $100,000-odd on a proposal before deciding, at the last moment, to resume MCA funding after all.
Now it's Minister Sartor who waits, while the council lavishes energy on CUB, before pulling the rug at the last moment. As an exercise in humiliation it works, every time.
The council - surprise - couldn't win. Eighteen months ago, when Clover Moore's administration was new, CUB's then preferred developer, Australand, walked out citing "delay and uncertainty".
Now Foster's, as the site owner, pleads likewise. But look closely and you'll see who's been playing funny buggers.
The delay, as a process run by the Central Sydney Planning Committee, has actually been in government control all along. Uncertainty, under the minister, can only increase, since the move takes the CUB site from known and agreed limits (a 100-metre height limit and 4:1 ratio between built area and site area) to a situation that is wholly up for grabs.
As for the assertion by Foster's that "it's been a very difficult process" dealing with the council, consider this sequence of events.
Last July, the council wrote to the Planning Department requesting clarification on developer contributions for the CUB site. No response.
In January, the council sent the minister its draft plan and, in February, answered his queries on it. No response.
Negotiations on the voluntary planning agreement commenced, and by May 16 there was in-principle agreement. Emails from Geoff Donahue, communications director for Foster's, to the council, dated May 26 and May 30, confirm that Foster's was happy with the agreement and ready for a public announcement "on Monday".
Meanwhile, however, on May 25, Sartor faxed a letter to Moore. "I am advised," it said, "that a draft VPA has not been agreed on to-date despite lengthy negotiations." The letter threatened to declare the CUB site state significant, wresting it from planning committee control.
This forced Moore to call a special meeting of the planning committee. There, on June 7, the four Government members revolted without warning, using their majority to request ministerial intervention. It was, in the words of one councillor, Shayne Mallard, sheer "political bastardry".
The irony is that the product may be fine. Certainly it's the right site. If there's any block in the state positively begging for high-rise, high-density residential development, it's this one: southern CBD, huge site, major arterial, nearby UTS tower, public transport centre of the universe.
It's the process that sucks. Whether the main push is anti-local government, anti-Clover, ancient Frank-versus-Clover rivalry or the old ALP anti-women-in-politics-other-than-nodding-dogs, hardly matters.
From the public interest viewpoint, the test will be how high the towers, how much car parking (despite proximity to Central Station) and how many dollars flow from here to the otherwise unfunded Redfern-Waterloo Authority. By then, though, it'll be too late to cry foul.
Elizabeth Farrelly writes on planning and architecture issues for the Herald.
Friday, June 09, 2006
Frank and Clover fight but Inner City will be the Loser
eCouncillor was elected (by draw from the hat) to the powerful Central Sydney Sydney Planning Committee (read about the CSPC here) last September as the first appointee not endorsed by either the Lord Mayor or Planning Minister of the day. So it is that I am in the unique position to sniff out political motivations and ambush from either side. The 11th hour intervention by NSW Labor Planning Minister Frank Sartor (a former Lord Mayor and chair of the CSPC himself) to effectively take state control over the most lucrative development site in Sydney (valued at up to $1 billion) has all the hallmarks of a political fix designed to humiliate the Council and help-out the fraying state finances.
Sartor's letter to the lot Mayor and CSPC (undated but faxed 25 May) undermines the Council's complex negotiations on the public domain benefits from the massive development ( read Frank's letter to Clover here). The letter was marked CC Councillors John McInerney and Shane (sic) Mallard - but strangely my (Liberal) office never received a copy.
The CSPC held an Extraordinary meeting this week to consider its response to the Minister's letter (see agenda) and consider Clover Moore's response (see Clover Moore's letter to Frank Sartor). I sat through the hand ringing and polite talk from the government CSPC representatives for half an hour waiting patiently for someone to point out how outrageous this intervention was. In the end after one of Clover's familiar read on the record monologues, I had had enough. I spoke on the whole issue attacking the 'offensive letter' from Sartor as an act of political 'bastardry' and accused him of arrogantly taking the controls off the CSPC and Council so he can force in a gross overdevelopment and rip out as much money he can for the state budget. Leaving a legacy of over-development for the City of Sydney to clean up and live with.
My motion that :"The CSPC calls upon the Minister for Planning Frank Sartor to withdraw his letter addressed to the Lord Mayor on 25 May 2006 and indicate to Fosters and CSPC that he does not intend to use his powers under section 3A of the EP&A Act to call in the CUB development site, and to direct CSPC, Council and Fosters to conclude the Voluntary Planning Agreement."
The motion was moved Mallard and seconded John McInerney (a Clover Moore independent) and lost 3 to 4 (Council vs government). The final recommendation reaffirmed the CSPC support for the current draft controls agreed to in December and the development values they set out. This was passed unanimously and put the CSPC position on the record for the Minister and State Department of Planning. The CSPC then moved an additional motion then referring the whole project to the Minister for a final determination. That referral clause was disputed by myself as running up the white flag and surrendering to 'bully boy tactics'. It was passed by the CSPC with the 4 government votes to 3 Councillors against.
The CSPC and Council is very distressed about this shabby unprecedented treatment and the local community (Chippendale) are very concerned and angry. They fear further over-development and loss of the hard fought public benefits.
The questions that arise from this affair are:
- how long ago did the Minister start talking with Fosters about his concerns? (Answer - seems like months now).
- Why didn't the Director General of the Department of Planning who is a member of the CSPC offer to mediate this dispute prior to the current situation with public stand-off between Sartor and Moore? (Answer - because Sartor wanted a confrontation with his old nemesis Clover Moore).
- why was the CSPC not advised by the State government about increased levies on the project? (Answer - because the cash crisis for the Redfern waterloo Authority has only grown more evident as developers fail to show interest in the 'Redfern renewal').
- what level of additional development is the Minister considering in return for higher cash levies? (Answer - a 'flexible' level according to the Minister)
- how will the Minister take into account community feedback on the site? (Answer - seems not much as one of his key CSPC representative is not attending the community consultation promoted below).
Clover Moore does not escape this free of responsibility:
- How have the two jobs as Lord Mayor and MP for Bligh (both cover the CUB/Chippendale area) benefited the community? (Answer - seems not at all).
Council Calls Community Meeting:
Urgent Update on
Carlton and United Breweries Site
An urgent meeting has been called by Council to update the community on significant events surrounding the future of the Carlton and United Breweries (CUB) site.
7.30 pm, Thursday 15 June 2006
Medina Executive Sydney Central, in the Royal Mail Room
2 Lee Street Sydney (adjacent to Central Station)
The Minister for Planning, Frank Sartor, has written to the Lord Mayor at the eleventh hour seeking increased Floor Space Ratio (FSR) controls for the CUB site and last minute inclusion of the Redfern Waterloo Authority (RWA) affordable housing levy in the draft Voluntary Planning Agreement (VPA) that the City was almost finished negotiating with Fosters, the site owner.
The Minister's late intervention threatens to increase height and density on the site; to derail negotiations on the VPA; and to compromise the community benefits for residents, including the proposed 5,000 square metre public park and $2.5 million community centre.
The City of Sydney and Central Sydney Planning Committee (CSPC) signed off on planning controls for the site in December last year, with an agreed FSR range of 3.5:1 to of 4:1. The absolute upper end of the range is conditional on achieving high standards of amenity, heritage, design excellence, parkland and sustainability. The draft controls were developed to balance the owner's rights with environmental constraints and community benefits.
Over the past six months, the City has worked with the site's owners to complete a VPA to secure all public benefits. This process is occurring for the fist time under new planning legislation and the Council and CSPC agreed that the draft VPA be publicly exhibited with the draft planning controls.
The Minister's last minute intervention has caused uncertainty and resulted in the site's owner backing away from an agreement that was about to be signed. The City had received RWA advice that the State Government would separately negotiate an affordable housing levy. While that levy was expected to be around three per cent of the development value, it now appears a higher level is proposed, compromising the VPA and the intended public benefits.
This looks like the Cross City Tunnel all over again if the Government seeking up front fees in exchange for controls that benefit the developer but are contrary to the public interest.
SMH coverage below:
Slum city fears as Sartor grabs massive project
Sherrill Nixon Urban Affairs EditorJune 9, 2006
THE Minister for Planning, Frank Sartor, is set to take control of the city's biggest residential project, igniting fears he will allow enormous apartment blocks that will become Sydney's future slums.
The Lord Mayor of Sydney, Clover Moore, and Chippendale residents say Mr Sartor's last-minute intervention in the $800 million Carlton and United Breweries site is a blatant grab for more cash from the eventual developers.
They fear he will approve much larger apartment blocks on the Broadway site than the City of Sydney Council was prepared to accept, in exchange for higher developer levies which would be used to fund affordable housing in the Redfern-Waterloo area.
"The Government is looking for money here and you are just looking at the slums of the future," Cr Moore said.
The 5.7-hectare development, approximately the size of four city blocks, is expected to house about 3000 people in 1800 apartments - tripling the population of Chippendale.
It has been the subject of two years of difficult negotiations between the council and the site's owner, Foster's.
The huge blow to Cr Moore and her council came on Wednesday night at an extraordinary meeting of the Central Sydney Planning Committee.
The committee, comprising four government and three council appointees, considers city developments worth more than $50 million.
The meeting was called to respond to a letter from Mr Sartor, expressing concern at how long it had taken the council and Foster's to agree on a range of planning issues. In the letter, Mr Sartor also directed the council and Foster's to negotiate the affordable housing levy - a matter both parties, and the Central Sydney Planning Committee, had believed would be negotiated separately.
Cr Moore described the letter, which arrived just days before the council and the company were due to sign an agreement, as a "bolt from the blue".
At Wednesday's meeting, the government appointees used their majority vote to ask Mr Sartor to "call in" the development and assume planning control. Neil Bird, the deputy chairman of Landcom, told the meeting he did not believe the council and Foster's could come to an agreement following Mr Sartor's intervention.
"I think it's better to act professionally and request the minister use his powers," Mr Bird said.
Cr Moore, the Liberal councillor Shayne Mallard and the Moore-aligned councillor John McInerney opposed the motion, in a rare split vote.
"The fact is that the minister's intervention is nothing but political bastardry in my mind. It is designed to harm you [Cr Moore], it is designed to harm the council," Cr Mallard said.
But the committee passed a unanimous motion affirming its support for planning controls approved in December that restrict the highest buildings on the site to 100 metres, or approximately 33 storeys, and provide for a 5000-square metre park, child-care centre and community centre on the site.
Chippendale resident groups fear Mr Sartor's takeover would jeopardise those community facilities, destroy the heritage values of the site and lead to higher-density development.
Lindsay Charles, from the Friends of the Carlton United Site group, said that local residents believed the development allowed by the council was already too large.
"We have got the CBD on one side of us. If we have got this [development] directly behind us or we are just simply never going to see the sun again," Ms Charles said.
A Foster's spokesman, Troy Hey, said the company believed it was possible to have a higher-density development while retaining the community facilities.
He welcomed the likely takeover by Mr Sartor as a way of providing more certainty for Foster's, but conceded it meant going over a lot of ground that had already been the subject of negotiations with the council.
A spokeswoman for Mr Sartor, Zoe Allebone, said the minister would seek advice about whether to assume control of the development, but believed doing so could cut six to 12 months off the approval process.
Moore and Sartor trade blows over city brewery site
Sherrill Nixon Urban Affairs EditorJune 10, 2006
THE Lord Mayor of Sydney, Clover Moore, has sought assurances from the State Government that money raised from the development of the Carlton & United Breweries site on Broadway will be spent on affordable housing in Redfern.
Cr Moore called on the Planning Minister, Frank Sartor, to "come clean" on how much money the Government would raise through an affordable-housing levy on the developer and how it would be spent.
The two leaders spent the day trading insults as Mr Sartor took advice about whether to assume planning control of the $800 million residential development.
More than two years of negotiations between the City of Sydney and the site's owner, Foster's, reached an impasse this month when Mr Sartor criticised the way the council had handled the talks and told the parties to negotiate the levy.
Residents and the council fear Mr Sartor will allow bigger apartment blocks to be built on the site in exchange for a larger developer contribution, at the expense of community facilities such as parkland.
"How can the minister claim to provide a balanced outcome for the community when he is ignoring expert advice and advocating for an increase in the size of the development which will see his Government reap a cash bonanza?" Cr Moore asked.
Mr Sartor said he had a record of guaranteeing quality public facilities and it was a "simple untruth" to suggest the development would be worse if he took over planning control.
"The Lord Mayor should concentrate on her administration," he said. "She's had two general managers and she should concentrate on doing her job better."
Mr Sartor also said the council was not capable of addressing the architectural quality of the apartment blocks or affordable housing, and promised that the levy - which is expected to raise about $30 million - would be spent appropriately.
and today's SMH letters..
Developers the only winners in towering mess
Tuesday, June 06, 2006
John Marsden Condolence Motion
The Council notes with sadness the death of solicitor John Marsden AM, and acknowledges his significant contribution to the community in the areas of human rights, civil liberties, gay and lesbian law reform and the legal profession. Council expresses its condolences to John's family and colleagues at Marsdens Law Group.
Motion moved by Councillor Shayne Mallard:
At John Marsden's epic funeral held at Campbelltown on Saturday, John wrote his own brief eulogy as the introduction to the glossy 24 page Eucharist program, "I have been described as tough, arrogant, noisy, outrageous, over the top, mega ego - but a tenacious fighter for what I want and what I think is right. "
Typical John Marsden.
Michael Knight said that Marsden's enemies described him as 'Offensive, rude, arrogant, abusive and a bully' and that all his friends agreed with that description.
John Marsden was either loathed or loved. As controversial in death as he was in life. John would have liked that too.
I do not want to dwell on the commentary about John's so called 'flaws'. Few published words about them have been balanced and too many have been cowardly. I will leave it to the distant historians perhaps not yet born to assess John's contribution to our times more objectively.
Instead, I stand here tonight as a good friend of the late John Marsden asking this Council to join with me in acknowledging the tremendous dedication and commitment to our vast and diverse community made by John during his 64 year life and to convey our thanks and condolences to John's family and also his colleagues. I particularly want to acknowledge John's sister Jane in the public gallery tonight.
Justice Michael Kirby described one's curriculum vitae and awards as the 'froth and bubble' of life. He went on to acknowledge the two key pillars of John Marsden's life - courage to himself and kindness to those worse off.
But tonight I do want to take a few minutes to acknowledge the 'froth and bubble' of John's life, because as we go through our own lives it is that froth and bubble - that work we do for our communities - that sustain and nourish so many of us. And local government seems so much about the froth and bubble of our daily toil.
John's life had a lot of Kirby's froth and bubble. It was calculated he devoted 140 volunteer years to roles with many community organisations spread across this city.
In the back of John's funeral program is reprinted his CV. Four pages of tight script detailing his work for various communities and awards presented by them in tributes during his lifetime. Let me outline a few:
From 1981 until recent years very active in the Law Society of NSW including a distinguished year as the NSW President.
He was the state president for the Council for Civil Liberties for 6 years and made a life member.
He was a director of various charities and community causes including Odyssey House and the magnificent Campbelltown City Art Gallery.
Member, director and life member of various sports bodies in his beloved Campbelltown.
He campaigned for many causes such as Aboriginal reconciliation and refugee support.
And of course he was awarded an Order of Australia.
But aside from Phillip Street - the Law, and Macquarie Street - Civil Liberties, the area that John worked most to support our City of Sydney was Oxford Street for Gay and Lesbian law reform.
Stretching from his decision as a closeted gay man to drive in to the city and help the first Mardi Gras marches - known as the 78's who had been locked up by Police in Darlinghurst gaol - John's courage for the causes of Gay and Lesbian law reforms and equality were untiring:
20 years as honary solicitor for the gay and lesbian Counselling Service
24 years as honary solicitor for the Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras
Life Member of PRIDE
Foundation and Life member of the Gay and Lesbian Business Association
Elected to both the Mardi Gras and PRIDE Halls of Fame.
John is also remembered for his work with HIV AIDS organisations including as a board member of the AIDS Trust.
And when private reflective moments would take John he would recall the hundreds of AIDS funerals he attended, friends he buried and the estates he administered during the darkest days of the AIDS plague that ravaged the Sydney gay community.
This Council should acknowledge JoMarsdenden, flaws and all. As Confucius said - 'better a diamond with flaws than a pebble with none'.
He was generous to a fault, passionate about his causes, overwhelmingly driven by the pursuit of equality and justice in our society.
Colourful, larger than life. I think that sadly we shall not see the likes of John Marsden again in our lifetime.
To John's wonderful family - particularly his sister Jane and his brother Jim, I convey my and Jesper's heart felt sympathy and sadness at your loss.
To his colleagues at Marsden's Law Group I also want to convey the Council's sympathy and respect.
Motion passed unanimously.
Friday, June 02, 2006
Clover misses the point on Light Rail tour
Mayors' US transport trip
EXCLUSIVE By LILLIAN SALEH, Urban Affairs Reporter
June 02, 2006
DELEGATES from three Sydney councils will head to the US tomorrow to find out what we already know  our transport system is ailing and in urgent need of an upgrade.
Ratepayers will pay $16,000 for the Mayor of Canterbury and Leichhardt's environment management director to criss-cross several US states for a week.
Parramatta's Mayor will join them but his costs will be covered by a scholarship.
The tour will be led by Sydney University Professor Ed Blakely, who until recently headed the State Government's metropolitan strategy reference panel.
Canterbury Mayor Robert Furolo, Parramatta Mayor David Borger and Leichhardt Council director of environment and community management Leta Webb will join Mr Blakely as they tour San Francisco, San Jose, Oakland, Pleasant Hill, Portland, Denver, Dallas and Washington DC.
They will study cities which have embraced a transit oriented development approach to planning, which involves designing developments around better public transport systems.
Mr Blakely said the delegates would investigate how some US cities had successfully been revitalised by improving light and heavy rail networks and reducing reliance on cars.
He defended the tour and said it was vital local councils kept up with world practice. "Most reporters wouldn't want to do this much work," he said.
"The issue here is you can't be a leader without knowledge. We are part of the world and we need to know what's going on."
Sydney Lord Mayor Clover Moore  who is a big fan of light rail and discussed the idea of the tour with Mr Blakely several months ago  yesterday said she declined his invitation because she did not believe in spending ratepayers' money on "junkets".
"Clover doesn't go on junkets," a spokesman said. All three councillors denied the trip was a junket.
Leichhardt Council delegate Leta Webb said the study tour would prove invaluable when putting together the area's new local environment plan.
"This is a highly structured activity. I know there are some study tours that involve councillors going on a holiday . . . but this is not one of those," she said.
Parramatta Mayor David Borger, who initially withdrew from the tour because his wife is pregnant, will go after securing a Sydney University scholarship.
Mr Borger, who is studying for a masters degree in urban planning, is considered a future key local government figure.
The Daily Telegraph
To the Letters Editor
Dear Editor
Clover Moore is not leading an important study tour of US capital city light rail systems because she has to stay in Sydney for Parliament and not because she 'does not go on junkets' (Mayors' US transport trip 2/06/06). The distinguished urban planning Professor Ed Blakely recently told a recent Sydney business association dinner that Clover Moore could lead the study tour at no cost to the ratepayers and that her second job as a state MP is distracting her from focusing on running the City of Sydney. Professor Blakely told the audience that she should decide which job she wants and quit the other.
When parliament is in recess Clover Moore packs her bags for her fair share of 'junkets' including trips to Japan, stop overs in Singapore and a fun night at the opening ceremony of the Commonwealth games in Melbourne - all on ratepayer's money. Most reasonable people do not begrudge her these perks as they are essential in representing our city. However, advocating a $1.5 billion light rail system for Sydney (financed by debt) and not participating in an independent study tour of similar systems overseas, is actually a lack of leadership for our global city and demonstrates yet again that MP and Lord Mayor are conflicting jobs.
Shayne Mallard
Councillor
City of Sydney

